Goodfellas Cocktails: Funny How? & Take Me to Jail

Looking for creative Goodfellas cocktail recipes inspired by unforgettable gangster movie scenes, iconic characters, and Martin Scorsese's legendary crime drama? Boozy Movies celebrates the 1990 classic with two original movie-inspired drinks: Funny How?, a bitter Italian amaro cocktail featuring kiwi juice, habanero bitters, and sparkling Cava, and Take Me to Jail, a refreshing Irish whiskey and crème de menthe cocktail with bright bergamot citrus flavors.

From Tommy DeVito's famously unpredictable sense of humor to Henry Hill's memorable farewell before heading to prison, these cocktails capture the tension, dark comedy, and larger-than-life personalities that make Goodfellas one of cinema's most celebrated gangster films.

Funny How? – A Cynar, Kiwi & Sparkling Cava Cocktail

Inspired by one of the most memorable and uncomfortable scenes in Goodfellas, Funny How? combines Cynar artichoke amaro, kiwi juice, agave, Peychaud's bitters, habanero bitters, and sparkling Cava for a bold, bittersweet cocktail with a refreshing fruit-forward finish.

Cynar provides the cocktail's distinctive foundation. This Italian amaro is made with a blend of botanicals that includes artichoke, creating a rich, earthy bitterness.

Compared with sweeter aperitifs such as Aperol, Cynar offers a more assertive herbal character that requires careful balancing.

Kiwi juice provides a bright, fruity contrast to the amaro's bitterness, while agave adds sweetness and helps round out the cocktail.

Peychaud's bitters introduce aromatic complexity, and habanero bitters contribute a subtle but noticeable spicy kick.

A generous topping of chilled Cava adds effervescence, acidity, and a refreshing finish that keeps the cocktail from becoming too heavy.

The inspiration comes from Tommy DeVito, the volatile gangster portrayed by Joe Pesci.

Tommy's unpredictable personality is reflected in the drink's combination of bitter, sweet, fruity, and spicy flavors.

The kiwi juice is also a playful reference to Tommy's past as a shoeshine boy and the familiar Kiwi shoe polish brand.

The cocktail takes its name from the famous scene in which Henry Hill compliments Tommy's storytelling, only to find himself caught in an increasingly tense exchange about what makes Tommy so funny.

What begins as a seemingly harmless joke quickly becomes an uncomfortable confrontation, leaving everyone at the table uncertain whether Tommy is joking or preparing to explode.

The combination of Cynar's bitterness and habanero bitters' heat captures that unpredictability, while kiwi juice and Cava provide enough balance to make the cocktail surprisingly approachable.

Bitter, fruity, sparkling, and lightly spicy, Funny How? is an adventurous choice for fans of Italian amaro cocktails, sparkling wine drinks, and unusual flavor combinations.

Take Me to Jail – An Irish Whiskey, Italicus & Crème de Menthe Cocktail

Our second Goodfellas-inspired creation pays tribute to the memorable scene in which Henry Hill and his associates raise glasses of a mysterious green drink before Henry heads to prison.

Take Me to Jail combines Irish whiskey, Italicus Rosolio di Bergamotto, crème de menthe, fresh lemon juice, saline, and orange bitters for a bright, refreshing cocktail with a distinctive combination of mint, citrus, and whiskey.

Crème de menthe provides the cocktail's immediate flavor impression, introducing a cool, minty freshness.

Irish whiskey follows with a smooth, grain-forward character that adds depth without overwhelming the drink's brighter ingredients.

Italicus contributes aromatic bergamot citrus notes and a delicate sweetness that complements the mint and whiskey.

Fresh lemon juice provides acidity, while orange bitters add an additional layer of citrus complexity.

A spritz of lemon peel oils over the finished cocktail enhances its fresh aroma.

The result is a surprisingly harmonious combination of mint, whiskey, and citrus.

The inspiration comes from a scene in which Henry Hill and his associates share a round of green drinks before he leaves for prison.

Although the exact identity of the drink shown in the film is uncertain, its distinctive green appearance inspired Boozy Movies to create a cocktail featuring crème de menthe.

Irish whiskey also provides a connection to Henry Hill and Jimmy Conway, two characters whose Irish ancestry prevents them from becoming fully initiated members of the Italian-American Mafia.

Italicus, meanwhile, represents the Italian cultural influences that shape the world of Goodfellas.

The combination of these ingredients creates a cocktail that is both refreshing and meaningful to the film's story.

With its green color, Irish whiskey foundation, and bright mint flavor, Take Me to Jail would also make an excellent addition to a St. Patrick's Day cocktail menu.

Goodfellas: Friendship, Loyalty & the Dark Side of the American Dream

Released in 1990 and directed by Martin Scorsese, Goodfellas follows Henry Hill, played by Ray Liotta, as he becomes involved in the world of organized crime.

Based on the real-life experiences of Henry Hill and the book Wiseguy by Nicholas Pileggi, the film explores the attraction of gangster life and the consequences of loyalty, ambition, betrayal, and violence.

Robert De Niro portrays Jimmy Conway, while Joe Pesci delivers an unforgettable performance as the volatile Tommy DeVito.

Lorraine Bracco plays Karen Hill, whose perspective provides another dimension to the film's depiction of organized crime and its effects on personal relationships.

The film is celebrated for its energetic storytelling, memorable dialogue, distinctive editing, and extraordinary performances.

In this Boozy Movies episode, we revisit Tommy's infamous dinner conversation, discuss the mysterious green drinks served before Henry's imprisonment, and explore why Goodfellas remains such an influential gangster movie.

We also discuss the film's cast, Martin Scorsese's direction, and the connections between Goodfellas and other celebrated crime dramas such as Casino and The Godfather.

What Is the Green Drink in Goodfellas?

One of the more unusual moments in Goodfellas involves Henry Hill and his associates drinking a round of bright green cocktails before Henry heads to prison.

The scene raises an interesting question: What exactly are they drinking?

In the Boozy Movies episode, we discuss our attempts to identify the drink, including examining the screenplay for clues.

The screenplay references a drink called a Screaming Eagle, but that name doesn't clearly explain the green cocktail shown on screen.

Rather than claiming to recreate the original drink, we developed Take Me to Jail as our own interpretation of the scene.

Crème de menthe provides the green color and refreshing mint character, while Irish whiskey and Italicus introduce flavors that connect to the film's characters and cultural setting.

It's a movie-inspired interpretation rather than a confirmed historical recipe, but one that offers a delicious reason to revisit the scene.

Gangster Movie Cocktails & Goodfellas Movie Night Ideas

Whether you're hosting a Goodfellas movie night, planning a gangster movie marathon, or searching for unusual Italian amaro and Irish whiskey cocktail recipes, Funny How? and Take Me to Jail offer two very different drinking experiences.

One cocktail combines Cynar, kiwi, habanero bitters, and sparkling Cava into a bitter, fruity drink inspired by Tommy DeVito's unpredictable personality.

The other explores Irish whiskey, mint, bergamot citrus, and orange bitters in a refreshing green cocktail inspired by Henry Hill's prison farewell.

Together, they celebrate the unforgettable characters, dark humor, and compelling storytelling that make Goodfellas such an enduring classic.

Join Boozy Movies as we mix, taste, and explore two original cocktails inspired by Goodfellas—because watching movies and making cocktails is what we do!

Goodfellas (1990). Directed by Marin Scorsese. Based on Wiseguy by Nicholas Pileggi

Performances by Robert De Niro, Ray Liotta, Joe Pesci, Lorraine Bracco, and Paul Sorvino.

A Warner Bros and Irwin Winkler Productions Production. Distributed by Warner Bros.

Tonight, we're diving into the world of Goodfellas with a specially crafted cocktail. Using Irish Whiskey, Italicus, Cynar, and more let's see if we can capture the essence of this iconic movie night in a glass. 

Funny How?

In a shaker tin, combine

1.5oz (45mL) Cynar

1.5oz (45mL) Kiwi Juice

1 oz (30mL) Agave

2 Dashes Peychaud's Bitters

2-3 Dashes Habanero Bitters

Add ice, cover and shake until chilled. Double strain into a chilled goblet with a sphere. Top with about

2 oz Chilled Cava

Garnish with

Firm Kiwi wheel

Take Me To Jail

In a shaker tin, combine

2 oz (60mL) Italicus

2 oz (60mL) Irish Whiskey

.5 oz (15mL) Crème de Menthe

.25 oz (7.5mL) Lemon Juice

Dropper Saline

3 Dashes Orange Bitters

Add ice, cover and shake until chilled. Double strain into a chilled Nick and Nora glass. Express a

Lemon Peel

over top and garnish on the side of the glass.

Cocktail recipes and instruction videos are created by Boozy Movies, LLC

If you like these cocktails, you’ll love:

If you like this movie, you’ll love:

Previous
Previous

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly - Movie and Cocktails

Next
Next

Anchorman - Movie and Cocktails